As we continue to prepare for our 2013/2014 season, one of the most common questions we hear from patrons at the Canadian Opera Company is "What is a good opera for a beginner?" We put the question to our staff, some of our artists and our social media followers to see what the results would be!
We polled our Facebook fans about the best opera for a beginner and the answer was The Magic Flute, followed by Carmen and La Bohème! Other interesting suggestions included Lakmé and Rusalka! Read on to see what our staff had to say.
Gianmarco Segato, the COC's Adult Programs Manager agreed somewhat with the Facebook poll. "I often get asked this question
– and the answer is deceptively difficult! My first go-to opera would be
something like La Bohème or another Puccini tearjerker like Madama
Butterfly. Certainly musically these pieces have immediately appealing,
memorable melodies which are often very emotionally-affecting for a first-time
listener. However, not everybody is comfortable with the over-the-top
emotions that Puccini can supply! I’ve had more success taking people like that to a spectacularly produced opera, and not necessarily a piece one would immediately
think of as “easy.” A prime example is a non-opera-going friend I brought to see the
COC’s Siegfried a few years ago. She was completely mesmerized by the
François Girard production (see image below) which I think she related to strongly as a visual
artist herself. So, it really depends on the type of
person you’re introducing to opera, and repertoire choices should be made
Vanessa Smith, School Programs Manager. "Start with whichever production piques your interest! Personally, coming from a theatrical background, I most enjoy operas when I enjoy the entire production. My first two operas were the first two on the mainstage when I started working here – Aida and Death in Venice. While I doubt many people would recommend Death in Venice as a “beginner” opera, I was so enthralled with the production that falling in love with the music followed suit. It may just be the visual learner in me, but when it comes to attending opera, I enjoy it most when the whole picture comes together."
Ensemble Studio member Clarence Frazer chimed in with a popular vote. "I would say most operas by Mozart would be great because (a) many people have heard of the composer so there already is a sense of familiarity in some capacity, (b) the majority of his music tends to be "lighter", very beautiful and have a memorable "tune" or melody which one might be able to sing themselves or hum once they're home, and (c) a lot of the librettos Mozart uses are stories which we all can relate to so understanding the opera and what is going on (with the aid of SURTITLES™) is not a dilemma."
Kristin McKinnon, our Assistant Publicist was also quite decisive. "Mozart’s The Magic Flute, without a doubt. Its catchy tunes and fun story make it the ideal introduction for opera newbies of all ages. Who doesn’t love a good fairy tale?"
Danielle D'Ornellas, Digital Marketing Assistant, added "I think I lucked out with my first opera, Le nozze di Figaro! I was very familiar with Mozart's music, but never really had a chance to explore opera. When I heard the familiar Mozart tunes tied in with the comedy onstage, I finally understood the unity of opera. It also didn't hurt that Ensemble Studio graduate Robert Gleadow played a mischievous and charming Figaro!"
Communications Assistant Claire Morley replied, "I think one of the best operas for beginners has to be Humperdinck’s Hansel and Gretel. It’s a familiar fairy tale to many, it is not epically long, and the music is whimsical and beautiful. There is a fantastic and darkly comic production that Richard Jones directed for Welsh National Opera and Lyric Opera of Chicago, and it’s captured beautifully on DVD in the Met’s HD Series. The Met production stars some faces familiar to the COC these days (Alice Coote as Hansel and Alan Held as the father, Peter), and both give tremendous performances. Particularly notable is the wonderfully hilarious and terrifying Witch, sung by the late Phillip Langridge (see image above). The opera is wonderful for both adults and kids, and every time I see it, I swoon!"
When it came to recommending specific operas, Jennifer Pugsley, our Media Relations Manager went tragic. "Jenůfa by Leoš Janáček wasn’t the first opera that I ever saw, but it was the first one that made me love opera. It was intense, thrilling and captivating from start to finish. What more could you want when exploring an art form for the first time?"
Gianna Wichelow, Senior Communications Manager, Creative. "I’d advise anyone who wants to experience opera for the first time to commit to a few experiences. I mean, if you see one movie and it doesn’t impact you, do you give up on all movies? No one opera can sum up the entire operatic experience. You can ask an opera-loving friend’s advice bearing in mind the sort of music and drama that you already find the most compelling. Having said all that, if I had to pick one, La Bohème is a generally good first opera. Carmen was mine, and it worked all too well!
Blanche Israel, Children and Youth Programs Assistant countered with "I say – go big or go home. I used to think a short, light Italian opera buffa would be the best way to introduce someone to opera, but ever since seeing the COC’s production of Wagner’s Tristan und Isolde (which left me figuratively sprawled out on the floor) I’ve revised my opinion. Opera is designed to awe and inspire, so a beginner should feel that right off the bat."
And Phil Stephens, our Senior Manager, Customer Service and Sales had the final word! "It depends on the beginner. Understand your personal tastes as an audience member… are you drawn to dark dramas, light comedies or something in between? A great leap towards connecting with opera is to attend a few plays, musicals and live orchestral events beforehand. After that, trust your instincts and don't hesitate to attend your first performance on your own. La Bohème has the music, young singers and storyline that makes it easy for newcomers to get on board, but pieces like The Flying Dutchman, Elektra and Ewartung/Bluebeard's Castle are my personal favourites because they’re gritty, twisted and violent (don’t judge me!). Tosca is another good one for its unbridled Italian passion and sharply defined characters (argh, that Scarpia!) Finally, Box Office staff are a wonderful resource, so use them. Let them know what you might be looking for, and they can help with some great suggestions. Ask lots of questions about seating and sightlines before you commit to the tickets. Then take a deep breath, and dive in."
What do you think is the best opera for a beginner? Something beautiful and melodic like La Bohème? Something challenging like Siegfried? Something dark like Peter Grimes? Let us know in the comments!
Photo Credits: (top) Adina Nitescu as Cio-Cio-San and David Pomeroy as Pinkerton in the Canadian Opera Company’s production of Madama Butterfly, 2009. Photo: Michael Cooper; (middle) Laura Whalen as the Forest Bird and Christian Franz as Siegfried in the Canadian Opera Company's production of Siegfried, 2006. Photo: Gary Beechey; (middle) Phillip Langridge as The Witch in the Metropolitan Opera's 2008 production of Hansel and Gretel. Photo: Metropolitan Opera; (bottom) Melanie Diener as Isolde in the Canadian Opera Company’s production of Tristan und Isolde, 2013. Photo:Michael Cooper.
Posted by Danielle D'Ornellas / in Parlando Asks / comments (1) / permalink
Sara Fulgoni in the COC production of Bluebeard's Castle. Photo: Michael Cooper © 2001